Oil Pastels vs Soft Pastels vs Extra Soft Pastels: Which One Should You Pick for Your Art Journey

Choosing the right medium can greatly influence your artistic experience. For beginners, the world of pastels can feel overwhelming due to the wide variety available. Each type offers unique attributes that cater to different styles and preferences. In this guide, we’ll explore the key differences between oil pastels, soft pastels, and extra soft pastels, so you can make an informed decision that enhances your art journey.

Contains Affiliate Links

What are Oil Pastels?

Oil pastels are composed of pigment blended with a non-drying oil and wax binder. This mix creates a creamy texture ideal for blending.

What truly sets oil pastels apart is their vibrant color output. For example, brands like Sennelier produce oil pastels that can have up to 90% pigment concentration. This results in intense colors that stand out on the canvas. Oil pastels allow for multiple techniques, including layering and using solvents, which can evoke a painterly feel.

However, their smooth texture may pose challenges for some artists. The colors easily smudge, so careful handling is essential to maintain your work’s integrity. Learn more about the difference between oil pastel vs soft pastel.

A vibrant assortment of oil pastels next to an oil pastel painting

Strengths of Oil Pastels

• Vibrancy: Oil pastels provide exceptionally vivid colors, which can make your artwork pop.

  
  

• Versatility: With the ability to mix in solvents, artists can achieve texture similar to traditional paint.

  
  

• Layering: Their thick application allows for unique layering techniques, enabling complex compositions.

  
  

Weaknesses of Oil Pastels

• Smudging: Colors can easily blend and smudge if not handled carefully, necessitating a protective solution.

  
  

• Blending: While blending is possible, it may not be as uniform compared to softer pastels.

  
  

What are Soft Pastels?

Soft pastels contain a higher concentration of pigment and less binder than oil pastels. This results in a powdery texture that produces soft, delicate lines.

Artists often favor soft pastels for their ease of use, particularly beginners. A survey showed that around 75% of novice artists prefer soft pastels for their forgiving blending properties. They can be applied on various surfaces like textured paper, but they require a fixative to avoid smudging.

A selection of soft pastels in various shades displayed on a flat surface.

Strengths of Soft Pastels

• Blendability: Soft pastels excel in creating smooth gradients, making them ideal for landscapes or portraits.

  
  

• Ease of Use: Their user-friendly nature makes them suitable for artists at all levels.

  
  

• Lightfastness: Many soft pastels contain archival-quality pigments, ensuring your artwork remains vibrant for years. Research shows that around 80% of soft pastels on the market are lightfast.

  
  

Weaknesses of Soft Pastels

• Dust: The powdery consistency can create dust, which may irritate sensitive individuals.

  
  

• Brittleness: Soft pastels can break easily if dropped, highlighting the importance of careful storage.

  
  

What are Extra Soft Pastels?

Extra soft pastels are an even creamier version of soft pastels, containing even less binder. This leads to luxurious texture and superb blendability.

These pastels shine in applications requiring fine detail as well as soft washes of color. However, their softness makes them prone to breakage, demanding gentle handling.

Strengths of Extra Soft Pastels

• Ultra-Smooth Application: Their formula allows for the smoothest application and blending, favored by many artists.

  
  

• Fine Gradations: Perfect for creating soft transitions, they help achieve dreamy, ethereal effects.

  
  

• High Pigment Concentration: Extra soft pastels often feature a high pigment load, enhancing color richness.

  
  

Weaknesses of Extra Soft Pastels

• Fragility: With their delicate structure, they require careful handling to avoid breakage.

  
  

• Less Control: Their creaminess can make precise application more challenging.

  
  

Oil pastel vs soft pastel vs extra soft pastel

When choosing between oil pastels, soft pastels, and extra soft pastels, consider these factors:

1. Art Style: What type of art do you love? Oil pastels are great for bold colors and mixed media uses, while soft and extra soft pastels excel in softer styles.

   
   

2. Comfort Level: Don’t hesitate to try each type! You may find a surprising preference based on how it feels in your hand.

   
   

3. Techniques: Think about the techniques you want to master. For instance, if layering is your goal, each type has unique strengths that can aid in your practice.

   
   

4. Surface Choice: Different pastels respond best on various surfaces. Soft pastels thrive on textured papers, while oil pastels work beautifully on smoother mediums.

   
   

5. Learning Curve: Beginners might find soft pastels the easiest entry point for their blending capabilities.

   
   

Embracing Your Artistic Path

In the world of pastels, oil, soft, and extra soft each bring distinct opportunities for creativity. Your choice should reflect your personal style and the techniques you wish to incorporate into your work.

Art thrives on exploration, so don't hesitate to experiment with all three types. Whether you discover the vibrant strokes of oil pastels or the creamy ease of extra soft pastels, let your creativity lead the way. Happy painting!